CMiC is the best all-in-one software for a general contractor, because it puts construction financials and project management on a single database. A custom system built by Black Badger ranks second, and it suits the contractor that wants one place for the field and the office without replacing an accounting system that already works.
The ranking, entry by entry
1 CMiC
Best for contractors that want one database for jobs and financials
An all-in-one system exists to end the argument between the field and the office about whose number is right. CMiC ranks first because it is built around a single database for accounting and project controls, and it fits general contractors, subcontractors and heavy-highway firms. A project manager and a controller looking at the same job are reading the same record, which is the reason to buy one system.
Watch for. There is no published price or tier list, and the pages we read do not state a deployment model. Both need a sales call before you can compare.
- How it charges
- Quoted by sales, no published price
- Main limit
- No price or deployment model is stated on its pages, so both need a sales call
2 Custom build by Black Badger
Best for contractors keeping their accounting and unifying the rest
Black Badger publishes this guide and builds custom software, and here that route ranks second. Buying an all-in-one product usually means replacing accounting, which is a risky system to replace. We build the other way around. Your accounting stays, and one system built for you holds jobs, field reports, changes and approvals and agrees with accounting through an integration. There are no licenses and no per-seat fee, and the code is yours.
Watch for. If your accounting system is the thing that is failing, a custom layer on top will not fix it. Discovery and a written scope will show which problem you have.
- How it charges
- One-time build scoped in writing, then running costs such as hosting
- Main limit
- Needs a scoping call first, and suits companies of 50 or more employees
What a custom build involves, and how to ask about one
3 Viewpoint Vista
Best for large multi-entity contractors with payroll and HR in house
Viewpoint Vista ranks third. Trimble describes it as a customizable enterprise ERP built for large-scale contractors, with deep data configuration and multi-entity accounting, and the family includes field management, HR and financial controls. For a large general contractor that owns several companies, that breadth is the appeal. It ranks behind CMiC here because those pieces are listed as separate parts rather than as one product.
Watch for. A mid-size firm should check that the setup effort fits. Trimble says all Viewpoint subscriptions include 24/7 technical support and Trimble Construction Academy training.
- How it charges
- Quoted by sales, no published price
- Main limit
- Described as an enterprise ERP for large contractors, with no published price
4 Procore
Best for contractors happy to pair a platform with separate accounting
Procore is fourth on an all-in-one list because it does not claim to be one. The pages we read describe connecting financials through accounting integrations, with job costs syncing to your accounting software. For many general contractors that pairing is all-in-one enough, and it lets each side use a tool made for its work. It ranks below the single-database products because two systems still have to be kept in agreement.
Watch for. A contractor that wants accounting, payroll and project management from one vendor is not who Procore is for. Ask how the sync with your accounting system works.
- How it charges
- Annual fee by product, based on construction volume
- Main limit
- Priced on your annual construction volume, so cost rises as your work grows
5 Sage Intacct Construction
Best for multi-entity contractors that want cloud accounting first
Sage Intacct Construction ranks fifth. It is cloud accounting with job costing and WIP across entities, and Sage sells a separate platform, Sage Construction Management, for the project side. Together they cover what an all-in-one buyer wants, from one vendor. It ranks here because they are two products, and Sage says you must have a Sage Intacct subscription to use Sage Construction Management.
Watch for. Sage lists a Construction Essentials package and a Specialty Contractor package as well. Check which package a quote covers, since no dollar figures are published.
- How it charges
- Quoted by business size, entities and modules
- Main limit
- Sage Construction Management needs a Sage Intacct subscription as well
6 Sage 300 Construction and Real Estate
Best for contractors and developers that accept hosted or on-site software
Sage 300 Construction and Real Estate, formerly Timberline Office, is sixth. It is deep construction accounting, and Sage lists Sage Construction Management and Sage Service Operations as related products for project and service work. It ranks low on an all-in-one list because of how it runs. Sage lists your own servers, third-party hosting or AWS as the deployment options, and none of them is a single vendor cloud.
Watch for. Sage says cost varies with the modules you choose and the number of users, with perpetual and subscription licensing both listed. Compare the two over several years.
- How it charges
- Quoted by modules and users, perpetual or subscription
- Main limit
- Runs on your servers or a third-party host or AWS, not as one vendor cloud
7 FOUNDATION
Best for contractors that want accounting and payroll built for the trade
FOUNDATION, from Foundation Software, is seventh. Job Costing, Payroll and Accounts Receivable are built in, and the vendor serves only contractors. It is on this list for the contractor whose idea of all-in-one is the back office. It ranks last here because the question includes project management, and this is not the product for a contractor that wants a full project management suite from the same vendor.
Watch for. Mobile Time Tracking, Service Dispatch and Equipment Management are add-on modules, and pricing is modular with no dollar amounts published.
- How it charges
- Quoted, modular pricing with paid add-on modules
- Main limit
- Modular pricing, with Service Dispatch and Equipment Management as add-ons